Penny + Grace: A Detailed Review

When it comes to monthly subscription boxes, the world of jewelry isn’t left behind. Penny + Grace is a standout player in this space, offering a delightful mix of minimalistic and trendy jewelry. Let’s explore what makes this subscription service sparkle.

Concept and Target Audience

Penny + Grace taps into the minimalist jewelry trend, providing pieces that are both understated and stylish. The service is ideal for those who love adding a touch of elegance to their everyday wear without going overboard. It’s particularly appealing to fashion-forward individuals who prefer a subtler look.

Subscription Model

The service operates on a simple model. Subscribers receive a monthly package containing three jewelry pieces. The interesting part is the customization; you can choose your color preference (gold, silver, or rose gold), and indicate if you have any metal allergies. This personalized approach makes each box feel specially curated for the subscriber.

Pricing and Value

As of my latest check, the subscription costs $29.99 per month. Considering you receive three pieces of jewelry, the price averages out to about $10 per item, which is reasonable given the quality. They also offer free shipping in the U.S., adding to the value. For those outside the U.S., shipping costs vary.

Jewelry Design and Quality

Penny + Grace scores high on design. Their pieces range from delicate necklaces to simple yet elegant rings and bracelets. The designs are contemporary, suiting a variety of tastes and styles. In terms of quality, the jewelry is crafted to resist tarnishing. Most pieces are made of stainless steel or brass coated with 14k gold, rose gold, or silver – a major plus for durability.


The packaging is a delightful aspect. Each set comes in a cute, reusable pouch, perfect for gifting or personal use. The attention to detail in packaging reflects the brand’s commitment to a premium experience.

Customer Reviews and Feedback

Customer feedback, sourced from platforms like My Subscription Addiction and A Year of Boxes, presents a mixed but generally positive picture. Many customers appreciate the quality, design, and the excitement of receiving a new set of jewelry each month. These reviews often highlight the joy and anticipation associated with the monthly surprise element. However, there are some recurring points of critique, such as a desire for more variety in the styles provided over time and the occasional repetition of similar designs in different metal types.

Exchange and Return Policy

Penny + Grace’s exchange policy is quite customer-friendly. If you receive a piece that’s not to your liking or fit, you can exchange it. However, they do not offer refunds, which is a downside for those who might want to discontinue the service after trying it.

Environmental and Ethical Considerations

The brand doesn’t explicitly state its stance on ethical sourcing or environmental practices. This is an area where potential subscribers who are environmentally conscious might seek more clarity.

Comparison with Competitors

In comparison to competitors like Rocksbox or Birchbox, Penny + Grace stands out for its focus on minimalist jewelry. While Rocksbox offers a wider range of styles and designers, Penny + Grace’s niche approach caters to a specific aesthetic.

Pros and Cons


  • Affordable pricing at $29.99/month.
  • Customizable options for metal type and allergies.
  • Stylish, minimalist designs suitable for daily wear.
  • Good quality materials resistant to tarnishing.
  • Attractive and reusable packaging.


  • Limited variety in styles over time.
  • No refunds, only exchanges.
  • Lack of clarity on ethical sourcing and environmental practices.

Final Thoughts

Penny + Grace is an excellent choice for anyone looking to build a collection of minimalist, everyday wear jewelry without breaking the bank. The quality, design, and customization options provide significant value for the price. However, if you seek a wide variety in styles or are particularly conscious about ethical and environmental practices, you might want to explore other options.For more information or to subscribe, visit Penny + Grace’s website.

Ivy Campbell
We will be happy to hear your thoughts

Leave a reply

Best Subscription Boxes

Our Social Life

Compare items
  • Total (0)